Episode 144 - Casino
Movie MistrialNovember 18, 2026
144
00:31:2128.71 MB

Episode 144 - Casino

We've had some audio issues on this one - sorry for that.


This week on Movie Mistrial, we roll the dice on Martin Scorsese’s glittering crime epic, Casino.

Powered by outstanding performances from Robert De Niro, Sharon Stone, and Joe Pesci, Casino offers a mesmerizing look at greed, power, and organized crime in Las Vegas. Scorsese’s energetic direction and attention to detail create an immersive portrait of a city built on risk.

Often living in the shadow of Goodfellas, Casino is sometimes criticized for covering familiar territory. Its lengthy runtime and relentless narration can also feel excessive for some viewers.

Join us as we place our bets on Casino. Is it an underrated gangster masterpiece—or a high-stakes gamble that never quite hits the jackpot?

Connect with us and share your thoughts:

Twitter: http://tiny.cc/MistrialTwitter

Facebook: http://tiny.cc/MistrialFB

Instagram: http://tiny.cc/MistrialInsta

Visit our website, www.moviemistrial.com, for more captivating episodes and to stay up-to-date with all things movies.

[00:00:00] Welcome back to Movie Mistrial, the podcast where we put the IMDb Top 250 on trial. I'm Johannes. And I'm Raji. Today we're heading to the bright lights and dark underbelly of Las Vegas with Martin Scorsese's Casino. Released in 1995, the film follows Sam Ace Rothstein, a meticulous casino executive whose pursuit of control is slowly unraveled by organized crime, personal betrayal and his own inability to let go.

[00:00:27] Richard Powerhouse performances from Robert De Niro, Sharon Stone and Joe Pesci. Casino explores greed, loyalty, obsession and the illusion that anyone can stay on top forever. But here's the question. Is Casino one of Scorsese's greatest crime epics or does it live too comfortably in the shadow of goodfellas? Let's flip the coin because today Casino is on trial.

[00:00:52] Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth so help you God? All right. Let's flip a coin, my friend. Let's see what's going on. I'm gonna go with heads.

[00:01:22] Heads it is. Okay. Um... Let me think. I'm gonna argue for this film. Oh. I'll argue for this film. All right. Well, um... I'll dive in then. Let's go. The witness will address this quote as judge or your honor. Ladies and gentlemen, Casino is a film that is all breaking a lot of the film conventions of show don't tell.

[00:01:51] Because this film is 95% exposition. And this is storytelling and Robert De Niro's character basically giving us, oh yeah, and this is this person. He's doing this thing and he... This is his story. And we don't see any of it. It's just kind of, um... Overlaid over a tapestry of the Vegas of the 90s, basically. And...

[00:02:16] I got really tired of just the exposition, exposition, exposition, exposition, and just kind of the talk and talk and talk about the things of an unreliable narrator. And, um... That was like 95% of the movie for me. The other 5% are pretty good. Because that is kind of the Vegas of the 90s. Kind of the fun Vegas. The pyramids of it all. The castles.

[00:02:47] Um... And, uh... The fictional casino that we have in this movie. And the whole allure of like all the money and the women and the drugs and everything that kind of Vegas in many ways stands for. And, um... Sprinkled in, of course, we gotta have some mob stories. Because it is Vegas and it is Scorsese. And it's a couple years after Goodfellas. And that made that person a lot of money. So let's, you know, bank more on that. And...

[00:03:16] Generally, I think the problem I have with this film is that it's not as good as Goodfellas. Uh... Structurally, it is a lot weaker because it is all exposition and it's all talking. And, um... What stands are performances. Mainly by Sharon Stone and Joe Pesci. I feel like De Niro is not necessarily the strongest here. I don't really believe his character that much. And, um... This film is very repetitive in that sense as well.

[00:03:45] Because, uh... Over the three hours that this film is going, um... There's not a lot new that changes, right? We have De Niro's character that is trying to... And is successful for a long time. Gain power and control. And, uh... Influence. And, um... Not a lot of changes there. Yes, there's some hiccups here, but... He's still coming out at the top, I would argue.

[00:04:14] Then we have Ginger, Sharon Stone. Who, um... Is falling further and further into... Drugs, basically. And, and... It's just kinda... It's a downward spiral for her. But there's also... It's a downward spiral. So it just kinda goes tangentially down. There's no real redeeming thing there. And then Joe Pesci's character... Is also fairly one note. Because he's the... He's the brute of it all. He's the... The muscle.

[00:04:44] The... The... Violent part of the film. And not a lot changes there. Until his demise. Which is... You know... Classic mob film. Just kinda brutal. Quick. Um... So this film's kind of a miss for me. It is... Structurally, I think it's a lot weaker than Goodfellas. Um... The redeeming thing is... Seeing Vegas of the 90s. I think Vegas is such a fascinating town that has...

[00:05:13] Changed itself over and over and over again. And... It's really cool to see a time capsule of that. Um... But if you want a mob movie... See Goodfellas. It's much better. If you wanna see a real... Kinda a better Vegas movie... I think... There are... A couple flavors that are interesting. If you want comedy... Go Hangover. If you want Heist... Go Ocean's Eleven. There's so many Vegas movies that are more compelling. If you want Crazy...

[00:05:45] Um... Uh... What's Viva Las Vegas? Fear Loathing in Las Vegas. There's so many Vegas movies that are... Inherently more interesting if you think about Vegas. And... Um... Yeah. I guess my argument basically is... There are many different movies that are better... Um... In their respective niches... Than this is... In... The broad... The kind of categories and niches that this film is tackling... In one film. So it's just kind of unfocused and not great.

[00:06:15] That's why I'm starting. I think that... This movie is an interesting... Um... It's an interesting look into... Multiple ways... Characters... Who are... In a sense... Connected to the mob... Self-destruct. We have... The person who... Um... Who is... Um...

[00:06:44] Who is flamboyant... Uh... Like Ace... Who wants to... Be the limelight... But makes bad decisions in his life. He's aware he's making the bad decisions. But... He can't stop himself from... Continuously making the same bad decisions over and over again. The bad decisions keep getting worse... And he keeps making the same bad decisions. So in a way... He's kind of addicted to... Making his life worse.

[00:07:14] We have Ginger... Who is addicted to drugs... Addicted to lifestyle... And addicted to... Addicted to life in Vegas. Um... And... She makes a lot of bad decisions... Including tying her kid to a bed... To go out. Um... And... The decisions that... All of this... Um... The drugs... Alcohol...

[00:07:43] The lifestyle... They make her take... Or she takes... As a response to those... Shows that... She's also... On a spiral downwards. And finally... We have... And Nikki... Also... Is addicted... But he's addicted to violence and power. And he is addicted to... The sense of not... Being weak. He's... He's been a member... He's a made man...

[00:08:12] A member of the... The family. And he's kind of an enforcer. Um... Everybody skims from the top. But Nikki is... Um... Addicted to becoming... A power... Uh... A power... A power hole... In Vegas. He wants to become big for himself. And as a result, he will do... Anything... Vitriolic... Violent...

[00:08:41] Um... To get to where he wants to be. So he's... He's driven... And addicted to the ambition... Of power. So you have these three... Intertwined characters... Moving through... Vegas. The land of sin. And you get a compelling story. Granted, a lot of it is... Narrated... Sometimes unnecessarily. Um... But...

[00:09:11] You get this dynamic of... Interconnected... Bad... Bad decisions... That keep spiraling... And spiraling... Until... Until the... The... The mob... The mob people... The mob bosses in... In... At home... Should I say... But we all know it's Chicago... Feel like they need to step in... And make decisions... And stop this folks...

[00:09:40] I will say... That... Sharon Stone's acting in this movie... Was really, really good. I don't think I've seen Sharon Stone in... In a better... I've not seen Sharon Stone act any better... In any other movie... Than... Than this one. And I know that you... You mentioned Goodfellas and all the other films... And you talked about how this one is probably not the best of it... Mostly because they do a lot of exposition. But I still think that this movie is... An extremely good film.

[00:10:09] It's really, really... It's really, really interesting. And the thing that makes it the most interesting... Is the pacing. From the very beginning of this movie... All to the very end... This movie doesn't stop. It's non-stop dynamic... Non-stop... Even if they're... Even if they're doing exposition in some... Some... In some places... The...

[00:10:39] The... The editing of this movie makes... This movie feel like it's moving really fast. And you don't get bored. I never got bored at all throughout this film. All the characters were very interesting. They were all... Very different. So it was interesting to see how each of them were... Creating a vacuum, a pool... Within their own atmosphere... Or stratosphere.

[00:11:09] Because you would see... Ace would be... Would be the leader of the casino. And he... He knows how to deal with the casino. He knows how it runs. He's able to control everything there. Um... Ginger was a... Was a... A sex worker... Who knew how to... How... Where to get things. How to get things. From whom to talk to. How to move the needle of Vegas... Towards her.

[00:11:39] And push all of that in her direction. And... You know... Nikki was the... Was the boss... Even if he didn't have a... Uh... What do you call it? A... A charismatic character... That draws you in. He forces himself onto you. And he does what he needs to do... To get... To get through. So... It's a very interesting dynamic... Throughout this movie.

[00:12:09] Um... And... You know... The movie... Unlike... You know... Goodfellas... And all the other mob bosses... We've... We've talked about... There's one major difference... Between all of them. Uh... Is that... Goodfellas was about people in the mob. And this one was... Simply about... People who wanted to maintain control... Um... Despite... Their circumstance... And in a sense... You get a totally different perspective...

[00:12:39] Than those movies... Uh... Because you're looking at things... From the perspective of how Vegas works. And how Vegas works... They give you the intricacies... They give you all of the nuances... And then they... They say... They plop you in the middle... And they say... All right... How will these characters... That we've described... Survive in a world like this? And I think that... That gives it enough of a... Enough of a... Um... Enough of a reason... For you to watch it. I think this movie is...

[00:13:08] Quite excellent from that perspective. Hmm... I mean the more I think about it... I think this film is... Is... More about... Kind of... How to collapse an empire... In a way, right? Because we see... Excuse me... Uh... Because we see... That... How an empire is formed... Um... De Niro's character is getting the assignment... To take control of... Of the Vegas beat...

[00:13:37] If we're talking in newspaper terms... And... Um... He's building it up... He's good at it... He... Um... He's... Firm... In a way... But he's not brutal... Right? He... He makes a lot of money... For the bosses... Right? And then... The muscle comes in... And... I guess coincidentally... Or not coincidentally... Um... Ginger is the... The person that... Brings everything down... And...

[00:14:08] I think there's something interesting there... It's just the... So... If we just take that story for granted... I think... Um... There is a good movie in here somewhere... But I think the way this movie is made... Or this movie is constructed... Um... And the movie that we got... Is not necessarily the best way to tell that story... Um... Because like I said... To me it just feels kind of too frantic... And too... Um... Unfocused in many ways... And too...

[00:14:39] Um... Narration heavy... Um... For it to... To really... It's almost like... Scorsese didn't trust his audience... To... Take what... He shows them... And kind of... Figure out what he wants... Everything had to be explained by an offscreen narrator... Um... More context needed to be... Given... By a narrator... And I just wonder why... Because it's... It's like...

[00:15:07] It feels so... Um... Distracting... To me it was very distracting... Just seeing all these kind of unrelated stories... About other people... Um... Or sometimes the people that we see on screen... And... To me that's just the biggest weakness... And... And granted... The... And I say this a lot on this... On this podcast... But... The story that we have here at the core... Is not very complex...

[00:15:37] So... I really wonder why this had to be a three hour movie... Um... Because the story that we have is... It's not that... Hard of a story to tell... I don't think... It's... Not the most complex story... It's... Not a lot of characters... Um... And the characters that we are getting... Are sometimes still superficial... I think Sharon Stone's Ginger... Um... She is... She's pulling a lot of weight... And she is making it work... I don't think she got a lot to work with...

[00:16:07] And she... And that truly shows how good she is... Because her character is... Like I said... I think it's the driving force between... That is... Basically telling this downfall story... And good for her... But... Uh... I feel like the script didn't give her much... Um... To really work with... And she nailed it...

[00:16:38] Um... Because it's... It's another De Niro movie... He's... He's doing that... And then Joe Pesci is... Just kind of the... The mob character... Right? So... It's... It just feels... It wants to be multi-dimensional... And complex... But... I think what we were actually getting is pretty... One-dimensional... And not super complex... And then it's just drawn out... And... Um... Yeah... Again... Um... If...

[00:17:05] There are so many other movies that play in Vegas... That have similar... Story focuses... Of course they're not all mumbled together... But... Uh... You know... If you're more interested in kind of the ginger story of it all... Watch Showgirls... It's so much more fun... Um... If you want... You know... There are countless of movies that are better than this... In my opinion... That are also dealing with Vegas... If you want that Vegas angle... Um... So... This one's a... Is a miss... For me...

[00:17:34] Interesting... I... I... I... I kind of... I kind of disagree... In... In many aspects... Because I do feel like... One of the things that we... Should consider... Especially when we're talking about the length of the film... Is that... We wanted to... We want to stew... In... The debauchery... Of... Time in Vegas... We want to... Appreciate... What they're talking about... And you know... I've inferred many times... That... They narrated a lot...

[00:18:04] To kind of drive the direction of the conversation... Which is true... But they also showed quite a bit about... Some of the inner workings... And sometimes... Those inner workings are very nuanced... I'll give you one example... The scene where the guy comes in... And goes into the... Into the locker... Takes out the money... And just walks out... And they're talking about... And they're saying like... Hey... The accountants are counting the money... From the perspective of the viewer... When they see the people counting the money...

[00:18:32] It's perfectly normal for them to expect... Somebody comes in with a bag... And takes the money out... Nobody knows where that money is going... Or where that money is going... Or what that money is doing... I think that in a scenario like that... I think the nuances... Given how complicated... And how complex this... This mob star style is going through... Is an example of how... You know... The narration would help... In scenarios like that... I mean of course... There are also scenarios where... You know...

[00:19:01] Something is happening on screen... And we can visibly see it... And we can infer that violence is happening... And they still want to narrate that... Sure... I agree with you that... It went over the top... But I still think that there is... There is some value to the narration... Especially towards the end... At the end when we just added one new character... To the narration... Out of nowhere... I think it was... When they were asking... When the mob bosses was asking... About whether...

[00:19:30] Nikki was sleeping with Ace's wife... And we had a new narrator... Enter the fold... Only for that scene... And that was interesting... So I thought that that was pretty cool... And also at the end of the movie... When we get to see... The demise of Nikki... And he was actively narrating the scene... And then it abruptly stops... Once he realizes that...

[00:19:58] What was happening to him... I thought that was pretty cool... So I do agree that... There is quite a bit of a narration in the film... But I think that the way the director... Uses some of the nuances of the narration... Provides at least... A bit of... An interesting take... Even to the idea of narrating your own film... I also want to talk about the fact that... This is also a movie about Vegas...

[00:20:27] We get to explore the deserts outside of Vegas... The holes where people are buried... The rules of the mob... How the lack... The loss of control... Led to... Corporations moving in... At the very end... And Vegas losing... Its soul... In a sense... And... We...

[00:20:55] Vegas does play quite a bit of a... Of a role in this movie... And I don't think there's a lot of other... Movies that... The location of the film... Plays quite as high... A significant role... As Vegas does in this one... Yeah... I think that's... That's generally... The scope of conversation... I want to have about the film... And I'm... I need to go to...

[00:21:26] To... The sidebar... If you... Have nothing else to add... Yeah... Let's do the sidebar... Overrule... Briefcase... In my chamber... Sidebar... Yeah... Did you actually dislike this movie? Yeah... Everything I said is... How I feel... There were so many things... That just kind of annoyed me... The...

[00:21:55] One other thing... That I just remembered... It was a couple weeks ago... That I saw this film... But... We... There was one thing... When we go back to... And you see all these... Old mob bosses... In the back of the store... There was this one dude... That wore this... Semi-translucent red shirt... And you could see his undershirt under it... And it was like... Why... Why would you give him that? But then... It's like... Okay... You just go with it... Right?

[00:22:26] And then we cut to... Years later... And... I think it's a different store... That they're supposed to be sitting in... And... The dude is... Is there again... And he's wearing the same outfit... And it's like... Okay... So it's clear they... Just... Filmed this all in like two days... Um... You know... And it's just kind of like... A little bit of attention to detail... Like... That... That just... Started to grate on me on this... And like I said...

[00:23:10] It's... The story... Through people... Rather than being told about it... Um... Which is why there's this... Show don't tell rule... Basically... And... It's... It's just kind of mind-boggling to me... This... And like I said... On all the fronts... This... For me... This should hit all the boxes... Cast is good... You know... Location is kind of... Is interesting... I... Like Vegas as this bizarre...

[00:23:40] America... Thing... And... Mob movies... Are... Generally interesting... In a way... But they're also kind of... Samey samey... And... So... So at face value... I think this movie... Should have been right in my wheelhouse... But I just got more and more annoyed with it... And... Like I said... There's just so many... Different movies that touch on... All these little beats... That we are supposed to... Be getting here... That to me... Are more fun... Or more compelling...

[00:24:11] And... You know... Kind of quicker to pick up... That still give you that... That Vegas vibe... That still give you different aspects of Vegas... That still give you... Kind of... The seediness and raunchiness of... Of Vegas show life... As in showgirls... As flawed as that movie is... You know... That give you the gambling highs... And... And kind of the inner workings of a casino... As in... Ocean's Eleven... Right... They give you the mob aspect...

[00:24:40] There's tons of movies... Just in general... Right... So... Like I said... This film just kind of didn't cut it for me... And... It's one of these things where I'm like... Okay... It's a Scorsese film... And it's... By default... Kind of put on a pedestal... But... I don't necessarily... Fully understand it with this one... Alright... I think... I... I appreciate your perspective... I... I... I think this movie is...

[00:25:09] I think this movie is very good... I... I don't see... I mean... This is... This is a... We have... We have three movies in this... In this whole... In this whole... This whole saga... We have Goodfellas... We have Casino... We have The Irishman... The interesting thing was... The Irishman... They always talk... They talk throughout this movie about... The Irish... The Irish... The Irish... And I couldn't help but think about... The Irishman in... As a... As a movie that came out much later...

[00:25:38] Um... But... I... I thought this movie was great... I thought that the acting... The actors... Um... Especially Joe Pesci... Who played this menacing... Character... Who was always unpredictable... The scene in the desert... With Robert De Niro... Oh man... The guy said it was 50-50... And you never really knew... He was on a nice edge... Throughout that whole conversation... Uh... And the sense of relief... You get as the... The sand... Whipped into his face...

[00:26:07] As the guy drove off... Because it could have easily gone... The other way around too... So... I... I think that... You... Um... Also... Um... Uh... Sharon Stone's acting too... Was really really good... You really really... You could feel like... The emotional craziness... That was going on... With her... All of those... All of those... All of those... Dynamic... Uh... Ideas... Flowing through her brain... At the same time...

[00:26:37] A drug-graded brain... Uh... You could feel all of it... All the bad decisions... Gave you anxiety... Um... All of the... Uh... I will say that... They set up the characters... Very very well... At the beginning... So that when... Their lives started to... Intertwine... At the end... You felt... That there was something... That was going to spark... So... Um... Yeah... I thought the movie was... Very very good... I don't think it's as good... As Goodfellas... But I do think that it covers... Something entirely different... Um... I don't think...

[00:27:07] I think the Irishman is also... Not as good as this... But... I think that when you look at it... As a whole collection of stories... From that time... You get a really really good... Uh... A really really good overview... Of... Of the mob life... Um... I liked it... I liked it a lot... Um... Yeah... That's my overall take... Yeah... I think the Irishman was such a... That... Talk about a movie that is long... Which... Which of those movies aren't long? All of them are...

[00:27:36] Post two hours... I mean the Irishman was how long? Three hours? More... Right? Like that movie was... Long... Long... And feels like it... But yeah... Um... Yeah... I don't know... It's... It's just kind of... Uh... Like I said... This one... This one is one of these films that I... That I bought on DVD... When I was... 18... 20... 19... Whatever... Right? Like in that... When I was collecting films more...

[00:28:05] And because it... It was kind of touted as... One of the big greatest films... And... Mm... Again... I think... Goodfellas is so much better... In telling a mob story... Um... And for... For a lot of these aspects... I... I think there's a better film... That I... That I would enjoy watching more... I... I don't need to see this film anymore... And again... Because it's like... Uh... I don't know... Yeah... So... You know... And that's fine... That's fine...

[00:28:35] You know... Don't have... Like... Not all of them have to be... Kind of good... Or like bangers... Right? Um... This is kind of a hit for me... Or a miss for me... Um... And that's... That's fine... Um... Again... I... I'm more and more... Surprised by... The... I would call it... Lack of range of Robert De Niro... I think he's... I mean...

[00:29:04] I'm not entirely sure he has... Lack of range... I think he has some range... Well... He has... I mean... I wouldn't say that he has... The... The... The widest of ranges... And I think he's typecast in a sense... Yeah... To play the cool... But I think he has movies where he's not so... Where he plays more agitated roles... I mean... Taxi Driver is one... Uh... He doesn't play the cool guy there... Uh... He plays... In Cape Fear... He plays a scary motherfucker... Oh...

[00:29:34] Sorry... No person... Sorry... Um... And... Uh... I mean... Raging Bull also... Uh... He also... In The King of Comedy... He's telling jokes and shit... And shit... And shenanigans like that... So... I think that... I guess he may be typecast in a sense... Yeah... Oh... Don't forget he's also in... Meet the... Meet the... Meet the... Meet the fuckers... Where he plays the dad... Oh... Yeah... Right... Yeah... The comedy... Yeah...

[00:30:03] Yeah... So... I think... I think... I mean... He obviously has... He's typecast... But I think that he... If... You know... Given the opportunity... He would... He would... Uh... He would do what he needs to do... Yeah... Maybe... Maybe... Anyway... Um... That's all I have for this one... Thank you... Here... Um... I cannot do a good transition... Because I've not seen this film... I don't know what... What's happening...

[00:30:48] Um... Until then though... Where can people find us? You can find us on... Facebook... Instagram... And Twitter... Uh... Blue Sky... On... At Movie Mistrial... Or you can send us an email to... Contact at Movie Mistrial... Dot com... It was nice to talk to you... It's a talk at everyone... Yeah... And uh... We'll see you... Uh... Next time... Yep... See you with the next one... Have a good one... Bye... I'm... Bye... Thank you.